“Ache for home lives in all of us, the safe place where we can go as we are and not be questioned”: With Sikhs practically extinct in Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, India’s case as a natural homeland deserves a revisit as batch of 55 Sikh reached India

As 55 Hindus and Sikhs landed in New Delhi on a special flight from Afghanistan this week, the plight of persecuted minorities in India’s neighborhood once again came to the fore. These Hindus and Sikhs are one of the very last persecuted minorities who have been provided with visa assistance from the Indian government to help them escape from the torture in the Islamic Emirates of Afghanistan.

The persecution of Hindus and Sikhs in Afghanistan is a long story. While Guru Nanak Dev himself traveled to the country to preach, leading many Afghans to choose Sikhism, a large presence was also maintained by the migration of Sikhs to Afghanistan for trading purposes. During the partition of the Indian subcontinent in 1947, many Sikhs fled from Pakistan and found a safe refuge in Afghanistan instead. There are various estimates that peg Hindu and Sikh populations between 5 lakh and 7 lakh in the 1970s. Some peg this population at around 2,20,000. However, it sharply fell to 15,000 in the 1990s when Mujahideen came to power.

By 2016, only 1,350 Hindus and Sikhs remained in Afghanistan. Active discrimination against them has ranged from literal head counts of Hindus and Sikhs for elimination and a diktat to wear yellow armbands for identification. Religious persecution became a common feature of the Taliban rule as did the torture done to the ethnic minorities of Hazara, Uzbek, and Tajiks. About 99 percent of their population left the country in the last three decades with only a handful left behind waiting to be evacuated by the Indian government.

Despite religious persecution is a hard fact of life for many in Afghanistan, Western powers who pontificate on human rights and religious intolerance of other countries never bothered to recognize it as a legitimate facet of Taliban Rule. Neither were the persecuted Hindus and Sikhs recognized even once as refugees nor was any leniency given in deporting them back to Afghanistan. This has left them with India as their only hope.

Meanwhile in India, the subject of persecuted minorities from the Indian subcontinent getting citizenship has always sparked a huge debate. In late 2019 and early 2020, a series of protests rocked the country when the Narendra Modi government tabled the Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAA) that sought to give priority to these persecuted minorities in getting citizenship. Unlike the massive misinformation campaign that spread rumors that Muslims will be disenfranchised, CAA simply sought to reduce the years of naturalization required under the existing act by half. Even the cut-off was 2014, thereby not addressing the plight of persecuted minorities in more recent years. Although the CAA bill finally became law, the rules under the act are still waiting to be notified with the government seeking an extension from the past two years. There is a growing demand for increasing the cut-off to 2022 under CAA.

While India has always been a home to persecuted people worldwide with Parsis, Jews, and even Tibetans finding a safe refuge in India, the case of religious minorities is a different one. While all the other persecuted people come from a different background to India, the persecuted people in the subcontinent have a historical and civilizational link with India. It was the unfortunate event of India’s partition on religious lines that made these persecuted people a minority in what was once their own homeland. The need to address their plight has been highlighted across the political spectrum with former prime minister Manmohan Singh speaking on the matter in the Rajya Sabha in 2003.

The fact that the Sikhs weren’t allowed to carry their scriptures by the current Taliban government to India and the fact that Sikhs will soon be an extinct minority in Afghanistan should revive the case for India as a natural homeland for them. Currently, they are dependent on Long-Term Visas (LTVs) to stay in India and face multiple problems in settling here peacefully. Even the persecuted Hindus who arrived from Pakistan are living in miserable conditions in India.

History has been very unkind to the Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis, Jains, Christians, and other minorities in the subcontinent. Whether it was the partition in 1947 or the liberation of Bangladesh in 1971 or the recent return of the Taliban to Afghanistan, Islamic regimes have adopted a governance and justice system that outlaws any scope for survival or dignity for these non-Muslims. If they can’t come back to India which was once the land of their ancestors, then where do they go?

References:

firstpost.com - Monica Verma | The author is a PhD in International Relations from the Department of International Relations, South Asian University.