×
Skip to main content

Monday, 20 May 2024 | 05:51 pm

|   Subscribe   |   donation   Support Us    |   donation

Log in
Register


"The cost of false justice: a childhood lost": In an unsettling twist of justice, even minors aren't spared from the misuse of SC-ST Act, “I request CM & DCM to explain the meaning of POCSO, Atrocity, & assault cases filed against us”, asks an 8-yr-old

While children his age are engrossed in the simple joys of life, attending school, scribbling drawings, and reveling in innocent games, Vaishnav's life has been tumultuously upended
 |  Satyaagrah  |  Law
The Shocking Perversion of Justice: A Child Appeals for Understanding in Maharashtra
The Shocking Perversion of Justice: A Child Appeals for Understanding in Maharashtra

In a country that prides itself on its constitutional democracy, it's alarming and absolutely maddening to see how the SC-ST Atrocity Act, a law created for the upliftment of the oppressed, is being misused to target and persecute innocent lives. What's even more hair-raising is that this weaponization of the law isn't sparing anyone, not even children.

Deep in the heart of Maharashtra, a heart-wrenching episode has unfolded that stands as a glaring example of this distortion of justice. It’s not just another case; it's a testimony to the malfeasance rampant in our system. An eight-year-old boy named Vaishnav Satyawan Nimse has been thrust into the unenviable position of defending himself against allegations made under the Atrocity Act, along with other severe charges, including those under the POCSO Act.

While children his age are engrossed in the simple joys of life, attending school, scribbling drawings, and reveling in innocent games, Vaishnav's life has been tumultuously upended. He's not daydreaming about cricket matches or eagerly waiting for the school bell. No, instead, he's grappling with severe accusations that most adults would find hard to comprehend.

A netizen, who goes by the handle "History of India", brought to light a heart-wrenching video of this boy. The weight of the world is evident in Vaishnav's eyes as he says, “I’m an ordinary boy attending a normal school. While others my age are engrossed in everyday joys, I'm navigating the murky waters of the legal system, labeled under heinous accusations like POCSO and Atrocity Acts.”

Vaishnav narrates a troubling tale, detailing how a certain "Police official Nalavade" booked him and his family. The police, in their overzealous attempt to locate them, declared them 'absconding' when they couldn't find them in Junnar. Heartbreakingly, the little boy talks about how even his father and school teacher couldn't, or wouldn't, shed light on the matter.

His plea is simple yet profoundly poignant. He implores the CM and DCM for answers, trying to fathom the meaning of the cases filed against him. A plea that serves as an indictment of a system that allows such grave misuses of power and law.

This is no longer just about a law being misused. It's about a child's stolen innocence, a family's endless nightmare, and a society that needs to introspect about where it's headed. How many more Vaishnavs will it take for us to realize that something is terribly wrong?

The Atrocity Act's Cruel Double-Edged Sword

Laws, by their very nature, should stand as vigilant guardians of justice. But what happens when they’re abused to wage personal vendettas? Such seems to be the grim tale of the SC-ST Atrocity Act. While envisioned to shield the oppressed, it is now, alarmingly, morphing into a tool of intimidation against the common populace. The irony reaches its disturbing peak when you consider a mere child of 8 years, not even privy to the complexities of societal issues, being dragged under its heavy mantle. The sheer incredulity of the situation prompts a chilling query: Just where does the logic lie in this?

Flashback to August 2022, Rajasthan's historic city of Jaipur became the backdrop for a devastating scene. Rakshit Khandelwal, a 25-year-old budding chartered accountant, chose the abyss of death over the torment of witnessing his mother ensnared in the treacherous web of the misused Atrocity law. But Rakshit wasn't an isolated tragedy in this saga of manipulated justice. Only a month before, the train tracks of Churu bore silent witness to the desperate act of 26-year-old jeweller Uttam Soni Kudel. His leap in front of a speeding train was the culmination of threats from a vengeful woman and her associates, looming false accusations of rape and misuse of the SC-ST Atrocity Act as their weapon of choice.

Such dark narratives have become distressingly familiar, where young, promising lives are extinguished, not by fate, but by the egregious misuse of a law meant to protect.

The streets of Uttar Pradesh's Kannauj bore a somber mood when news broke out about Abhinav Pratap, a young 12th-grade student. Hopeful dreams and aspirations were snuffed out by the suffocating grasp of the SC-ST Atrocity law's misuse. Thrown behind bars based on accusations, his spirit crushed, the young lad saw no escape but to end his life. As if one tragedy wasn't enough, the Prayagraj (previously known as Allahabad) High Court's subsequent involvement further amplified the gravity of the situation.

According to a staggering revelation by The Economic Times, the Allahabad High Court directed the CBI to delve deeper into a slew of suspected fraudulent cases. This investigation aimed to uncover a nefarious network allegedly involving female-led 'gangs'. These groups, allegedly operating under the direction of influential lawyers and other prominent figures, schemed to trap unsuspecting victims under fabricated accusations. Their endgame? Monetizing innocence by extracting hefty sums post the filing of a charge sheet.

In the face of such revelations, a troubling question arises: Why is the media's spotlight so glaringly focused on one side of the narrative? Time and again, the emphasis seems to be on championing the cause of the so-called "backward classes". Yet, a deafening silence ensues when it comes to acknowledging the anguish of those from the general category, ensnared in the quagmire of baseless accusations.

Rakshit, Uttam, Vishnu Tiwari - these are not mere names, but symbols of a fractured system where justice seems to be on life support. The disparity is evident. If the scales of justice are to be truly balanced, shouldn't every victim be entitled to their rightful justice, regardless of their societal standing? The prevailing circumstances echo a resounding cry: Review the Act. Ensure that those who dare to manipulate it face the severe consequences of their actions.

Support Us


Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.

While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.

Pay Satyaagrah

Please share the article on other platforms

To Top

DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.


Related Articles

Related Articles




JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA