More Coverage
Twitter Coverage
Satyaagrah
Written on
Satyaagrah
Written on
Satyaagrah
Written on
Satyaagrah
Written on
Satyaagrah
Written on
JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA
Supreme Court refused to suspend Sanjiv Bhatt’s life sentence in the 1990 custodial death case of Prabhudas Vaishnani, ordering swift appeal hearing while firmly rejecting bail citing custodial torture allegations and Bhatt’s drug planting conviction

In a major development, the Supreme Court today rejected the application of former Gujarat IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt, who had sought suspension of his life sentence in a custodial death case dating back to 1990. Bhatt, who was expelled from service, had requested bail while his appeal against conviction was pending.
|
A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta firmly declined to release Bhatt on bail. However, offering some relief, the bench instructed that the hearing of his criminal appeal must be conducted swiftly. “We are not inclined to enlarge the appellant on bail. Our observations made herein above are restricted to bail only and will have no bearing on the appeals of the Appellant and co-accused. The prayers sought by the Appellant is dismissed, however, the hearing of the appeal is directed to be expedited,” pronounced Justice Mehta while delivering the order.
The case had reached this stage after the Supreme Court, on February 28, reserved its decision on Bhatt’s application. The application was part of the Special Leave Petition (SLP) Bhatt had filed to challenge the January 2024 judgment of the Gujarat High Court, which upheld his conviction and the life sentence awarded earlier.
The roots of the case go back to November 1990, when Prabhudas Madhavji Vaishnani died allegedly due to custodial torture. At that time, Sanjiv Bhatt was serving as the Assistant Superintendent of Police (ASP) in Jamnagar. During a Bharat Bandh that led to rioting, Bhatt, along with other police officers, detained around 133 people, including Vaishnani. Tragically, Vaishnani, after spending nine days in custody, passed away ten days after being released on bail.
Following his death, serious allegations emerged against the police officers. An FIR was filed against Bhatt and several others, accusing them of custodial torture. Although the Magistrate took cognizance of the matter in 1995, the proceedings faced a significant delay because the Gujarat High Court had stayed the trial until 2011. It was only after the stay was lifted that the trial finally commenced.
In June 2019, the Sessions Court of Jamnagar found Sanjiv Bhatt and a constable named Pravinsinh Zala guilty. Both were sentenced to life imprisonment after being convicted under Sections 302 (murder), 323 (voluntarily causing hurt), and 506(1) (criminal intimidation) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Along with them, police constables Pravinsinh Jadeja, Anopsinh Jethva, Kesubha Dolubha Jadeja, and police sub-inspectors Shailesh Pandya and Dipakkumar Bhagwandas Shah were convicted under Sections 323 and 506(1) for acts of custodial torture.
Challenging their conviction, Bhatt, Zala, Shah, and Pandya approached the Gujarat High Court in 2019. However, their hopes were dashed when a division bench comprising Justices Ashutosh Shastri and Sandeep N. Bhatt dismissed their appeals. The Court agreed with the reasoning provided by the Jamnagar Sessions Court, stating that there was no ground to interfere with the order of conviction.
Sanjiv Bhatt's petition before the Supreme Court was filed through his Advocate-on-Record (AoR), Rajesh Inamdar.
Appearing for Bhatt before the Supreme Court, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal strongly argued that Bhatt had already been in custody for over five years. Sibal contended that there was no solid evidence linking Bhatt to the custodial death. He emphasized that medical reports suggested the deceased, Prabhudas Madhavji Vaishnani, suffered from pre-existing health conditions. “There was no medical evidence of any physical torture. The death happened about twenty days after the release of the victim from custody,” Sibal pointed out. He further argued that Vaishnani had visited his family doctor immediately after his release and made no complaint of police torture at that time.
However, the State of Gujarat, represented by Senior Advocate Maninder Singh, presented a different picture. Refuting the defense arguments, Singh stated that the medical evidence clearly showed that the victim's death resulted from renal failure. According to Singh, this kidney failure was directly caused by the "forceful sit-ups and crawling" that the victim was subjected to by the police through the night. “There was clear evidence that torture led to kidney problems,” Singh asserted. He also reminded the Court that Bhatt was already serving a 20-year sentence in another criminal case involving the planting of drugs to falsely implicate an individual. Singh firmly stated that considering the strong evidence and Bhatt’s other criminal antecedents, there were no justifiable reasons to suspend his sentence.
The case has been formally listed as SANJIV KUMAR RAJENDRABHAI BHATT v. THE STATE OF GUJARAT AND ANR., SLP(Crl) No. 11736/2024.
Representing Bhatt were Senior Advocates Kapil Sibal and Devadatt Kamat, along with Advocates Rajesh G. Inamdar and Shashwat Anand. For the State of Gujarat, Senior Advocate Maninder Singh led the case, while Advocate Vanshaja Shukla appeared for the informant, who is the brother of the deceased.
Support Us
Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.
While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
ICICI Bank of Satyaagrah | Razorpay Bank of Satyaagrah | PayPal Bank of Satyaagrah - For International Payments |
If all above doesn't work, then try the LINK below:
Please share the article on other platforms
DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.
Related Articles
- "Unheard of:" Bombay High Court deprecated Maharashtra government for keeping a 21-year-old student Nikhil Bhamre in jail for a social media post that did not even name NCP Chief Sharad Pawar
- "प्यार तूने क्या किया": In Kolkata, 36-year-old divorcee Sanghati Paul stabs 30-year-old Sarthak Das, her live-in partner, multiple times, Das treated her son as his own, Paul confessed to the crime, igniting a city-wide debate on hidden feminism dangers
- "Every sinner has a future": In the labyrinth of justice, where Chandrakant Jha, with 18 murders, finds another chance at parole, it begs the question: Is redemption possible for everyone, or are some paths too dark to ever find the light again
- "Judge saheb ko bura laga kya… nahi, bas yunhi pooch riya hun": CJI Ramana slams Indian media amid the backlash judiciary is facing over controversial remarks and judgements, says ‘Media running agenda-driven debates and kangaroo courts’
- "Order Order बाद में, पहले exam की तैयारी करो": President Murmu champions the All India Judicial Service, aiming to revolutionize judicial recruitment across states, akin to UPSC's nationwide approach – a transformative stride in India's legal landscape
- SC's interim order restraining mosque surveys under the Places of Worship Act sends a troubling signal, empowering mob veto and prioritizing 'harmony' over constitutional rights and judicial independence, raising serious concerns for democracy
- "गुस्ताख़ी-ए-फ़रिश्ता": Delhi High Court dismisses Waqf Board's plea against Sunehri Bagh Mosque's demolition, led by chairman of the Delhi Waqf Board, Amanatullah Khan; NDMC seeks public insights, inviting suggestions and objections
- 'Found stone carvings of Hindu Gods-Goddesses, lotus, Seshnaag, Shrigar Gauri shrine distinctly visible, absolute remnants of ancient Hindu temple': Survey commissioner Ajay Mishra reports, Muslim side continuously uncooperative
- "अल्हम्दुलिल्लाह!!! Mob has no religion": The Rajasthan High Court grants bail to 18 Islamists accused in the Hindu Shobha Yatra attack in Chittorgarh, highlighting the challenges of pinpointing culprits amidst the chaos of mob-induced communal violence
- “A bench of Justices chosen through collegium got to choose to decide who has the better lawyer”: Karnataka government supports High Court verdict upholding marital rape charges against husband which is another stark violation of human rights
- "Mediocre minds usually dismiss anything which reaches beyond their own understanding": Allahabad HC dismisses PIL seeking Judicial Probe into death of 63 children at Gorakhpur Hospital in 2017, UP Govt had terminated services of Dr. Kafeel Ahmad Khan
- In an unexpected turn, the Supreme Court acquits woman accused of killing her newborn; says High Court, trial court possibly didn't respect her right to privacy, it's enlightening to see how privacy might now overshadow the scales of justice, isn't it?
- "Delay is the deadliest form of denial": Supreme Court grants temporary respite in Gyanvapi row, halting ASI's survey till Wednesday 5pm, the bench chaired by CJI D Y Chandrachud paid heed to the submissions made by senior advocate Huzefa Ahmadi
- "Freedom by expiry": Jailed in 1977 for a murder he didn’t commit, 104-year-old Lakhan Pasi walks free after 48 years—just as the Supreme Court begins its 2-month summer vacation, because what’s a lifetime lost when justice can nap in May and June
- “A mother’s arms are made of tenderness and children sleep soundly in them”: Bombay High Court grants bail to woman accused of throwing her newborn baby from top of building, she was upset with her husband, and suspected of him committing adultery