More Coverage
Twitter Coverage
JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA
"आतंकवादियों को आधी रात, मरीजों को सिर्फ तारीख": While the Supreme Court held historic midnight hearings for Yakub Memon and Teesta Setalvad, a cancer patient died waiting through 57 listings for the Kerala High Court to lower life-saving drug costs

A deeply heartbreaking incident has come to light where an Indian woman suffering from breast cancer passed away, 57 listings later, awaiting a verdict on her request to lower the price of a highly expensive life-saving drug. This tragic event highlights a stark disparity in how urgency is defined within the legal system. The woman had approached the Kerala High Court in June 2022, requesting access to life-saving breast cancer medicines named Ribociclib and Abemaciclib, which cost around ₹1.5 lakh a month.
To break down these staggering figures, Ribociclib costs about ₹78,468.75 per month, and Abemaciclib, which is sold at ₹47,752 to ₹95,504 per month.
The cost of the drugs was beyond what a woman or any ordinary person in India could afford. Because the financial burden was entirely impossible for a normal citizen to bear, she had approached the Kerala High Court through a petition seeking its intervention to make the drugs accessible at lower and more affordable prices.
In her petition, she had requested a government-use license under Section 100 of the Patent Act, which would have facilitated the local production of a generic version of the drug and could have enabled access to the drug at affordable prices. Notably, generic versions of medicines are 90%-95% cheaper than those of the originator, offering a massive price reduction that could make treatment viable for regular citizens. However, the government refused to issue a government-use license for the drugs, stating that breast cancer did not constitute a matter of national urgency. In such a situation, a timely decision of the court could have been crucial in saving a precious life.
The drugs remain inaccessible to many patients due to high costs and patent protection, which prevents other manufacturers from producing or selling the medicine at lower prices without the consent of the patent holders. The matter was repeatedly listed before the High Court, as many as 57 times and adjourned 40 times and placed before 8 different judges. It was listed on January 21, 2023, for an exclusive final hearing, but the hearing was postponed because of a roster change. Tragically, the bureaucratic scheduling outlasted the medical reality, as the patient passed away in September 2022, awaiting the verdict on her request.
|
The Fatal Consequence of Legal Adjournments
Following her death, the High Court, on September 16, 2022, decided to continue hearing the matter as a suo motu case—an action taken by the court on its own accord—under the title ‘In Re Exorbitant Pricing of Life Saving Patented Medicines.’ The matter is scheduled for hearing on 15th July before a Bench of Justice Harishankar V Menon. Before the next hearing of the matter, a letter was addressed by the co-conveners of the Working Group on Access to Medicines and Treatment, Jyotsana Singh and KM Gopakumar, to the Kerala High Court Chief Justice Soumen Sen, flagging the delays in the judicial proceedings. The letter has also been sent to President Droupadi Murmu and the Chief Justice of India Surya Kant.
“The one who started this fight is no more. This fact shows how costly a delay can be, especially when it comes to life-saving drugs,” the letter stated, highlighting how the patient died awaiting relief from the court. It points out how the delays in deciding cases involving access to essential medicines deprive patients of their fundamental right to health and life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
The communication sent to the judiciary emphasized that these systemic delays represent a broader crisis for women's healthcare access across the nation. “Hon’ble Chief Justice, the issue at hand goes beyond individual suffering and addresses the collective health and dignity of women in India. Breast cancer disproportionately impacts women’s health, and access to life-saving medicines is essential for reducing preventable deaths. Delays in adjudicating cases involving access to essential medicines deprive patients of their fundamental right to health and life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which has repeatedly been underlined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India,” the letter stated. It further urged the Chief Justice to take administrative steps to ensure an early and uninterrupted final hearing of the matter.
During the four months of her life, since June 2022, the matter was listed 57 times before the Kerala High Court, but the judicial procedures outlasted the patient’s life. She was not asking for a privilege or special treatment. She was only asking for access to life-saving drugs that could have prolonged her life. She endured years of the painful disease and judicial proceedings, and finally lost the battle for her life.
She died in the early stage of cancer, even before hearing the final verdict on her petition. She left the world, hoping that the judiciary would give her a new lease of life by making the crucial drugs accessible. A timely court verdict allowing her access to the medicine was a crucial factor in upholding her right to life. However, the court proceedings moved with their own peculiar, leisurely pace, and she succumbed not just to her deadly disease but to the tiring, testing and prolonged court proceedings, where procedural compliances often override human life.
|
Defining Priority and Speed in the Legal System
This is not the only case where court proceedings have outlasted the lives of litigants. The Indian judiciary is known for its vast backlog of cases, slow pace of proceedings and often differential treatment of litigants, due to which court cases often pass from litigants to their successors or legal representatives. The present case brings attention to the cases where the Indian judiciary has shown exceptional and unprecedented vigilance in hearing cases for protecting the ‘rights’ of even a convicted terrorist.
On July 30, 2015, the Supreme Court of India, in an unprecedented and exceptional gesture, gave a midnight hearing to the plea of 1993 Mumbai serial blasts convict Yakub Memon, who sought the postponement of his hanging by 14 days. A Bench of Justice Dipak Misra, Justice Prafulla C Pant and Justice Amitava Roy heard Memon’s plea at 3 a.m. on July 30, 2015, the same day he was to be executed. Notably, Memon’s mercy petition was rejected by the President of India a year before. In a similar gesture, the Supreme Court formed a 3-judge Bench and held a hearing at 9:15 pm on July 1, 2023, to grant interim bail to controversial activist Teesta Setalvad.
While the Supreme Court’s unusual gestures in giving urgent hearings in the abovementioned cases demonstrated how the Indian judiciary is capable of timely disposing of matters it considers ‘urgent’, it also drew widespread criticism for giving differential treatment to certain people, including a convicted terrorist. Regarding the two cases, it was argued that these were matters of ‘life and death’ and ‘personal liberty’, which is why the urgent hearings were warranted. However, such urgency has since rarely been displayed by the Indian courts, even though they routinely deal with matters concerning the fundamental rights of people.
The present case of the cancer patient was no less ‘urgent’ than the cases of Yakub Memon and Teesta Setalvad. Her life was at stake and was eventually lost amid the procedural complexities of the judicial system. However, she did not get an urgent hearing because perhaps it takes more than just a ‘life and death situation’ or a threat to personal liberties to attract the Indian courts’ rare attention.
Support Us
Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.
While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| ICICI Bank of Satyaagrah | Razorpay Bank of Satyaagrah | PayPal Bank of Satyaagrah - For International Payments |
If all above doesn't work, then try the LINK below:
Please share the article on other platforms
DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.
Related Articles
- "It is only the cynicism that is born of success that is penetrating and valid": A five-judge bench of the Supreme Court on Monday dismissed a petitions challenging the Central government's 2016 decision to demonetise currency notes of ₹1,000 and ₹500
- Height of Hypocrisy in the land of Law where accused is hailed and acquitted, but victim is shamed by Court and Church: A timeline of the Bishop Franco Mulakkal case
- Only Dhimmis can be a good Hindu – An article on Shekhar Gupta’s ThePrint argues ‘defending namaz’
- Supreme Court steps in to decide whether Rohingyas are ‘refugees’ or ‘illegal immigrants’, raising critical concerns about whether the judiciary is once again overstepping its constitutional limits and assuming the role meant for the government
- In an unexpected turn, the Supreme Court acquits woman accused of killing her newborn; says High Court, trial court possibly didn't respect her right to privacy, it's enlightening to see how privacy might now overshadow the scales of justice, isn't it?
- In a major development, Mathura court allowed a plea to remove the disputed structure of the Shahi Idgah Mosque near Krishna Janmabhoomi for hearing: suit filed in the name of "Bhagwan Sri Krishna Virajman"
- "जालसाज़": MP High Court punished a journalist with a Rs 25,000 fine for misusing PIL to target a temple on Yashwant Niwas Road, Indore, citing vested interest, lack of evidence, and selective intent instead of genuine public concern, dismissing his plea
- "Power of the lawyer is in the uncertainty of the law": Kerala High Court - Nudity should not be tied to sex. Mere sight of the naked upper body of the woman should not be deemed to be sexual, Just as beauty is in the eyes of the beholder, so is obscenity
- “Chaos is merely order waiting to be deciphered”: MoP issue settled; government cannot conveniently cite views of few judges on MoP to oppose Collegium recommendations, scheme of our constitution requires court to be final arbiter of law ~ Supreme Court
- Supreme Court rejects Sanjiv Bhatt’s plea in the explosive 1996 drug planting case, as Kapil Sibal steps in to defend the disgraced ex-IPS officer amid mounting legal turmoil
- "जैसा बोओगे, वैसा ही काटोगे": Thirty-five years after Baljit Singh mysteriously vanished from Chabal police custody, a Mohali CBI court sentences fugitive ex-cop Kashmir Singh to five years in prison, bringing a dramatic end to a tragic Tarn Taran case
- "Some judges are like umpires who believe they won the game": Madras High Court, "If temples are going to perpetuate violence, then their existence has no meaning, better to close down those temples. The whole purpose of having a temple is of no use"
- A fire, burnt cash, and a judge under suspicion—yet the Supreme Court refuses an FIR against Justice Yashwant Varma, asking petitioners to first write to the President and PM, shielding its own while justice quietly exits the courtroom, unheard and unseen
- "A benefit is estimated according to the mind of the giver": Supreme Court rewarded series of privileges to retired CJIs, most notable are entitlement to domestic help, chauffeur and secretarial assistant for life, commencing from their date of retirement
- "Devotional songs of a Christian Yesudas rendered on Hindu Gods without any demur in temples": Madras High Court plays nosy-parker with Hindu faith stating that non-Hindus cannot be prevented entry into temple if he has faith in that Hindu deity

























